Culbertson’s Rule of Hand Evaluation by Jeff Lehman

Source: jeff.bridgeblogging.com

Many methods of hand evaluation abound: Law of Total Tricks (LOTT), the counter to LOTT in Lawrence-Wirgren book, Losing Trick Count (LTC), and, of course, point count.

I think all of those methods pale in comparison to Culbertson’s Rule, which I had read many, many years ago in Jeff Rubens’ great book The Secrets of Winning Bridge.  Rubens defines the Rule as “your hand is worth an invitation to game (or slam) if a perfect minimum holding from partner will make it a laydown”.

What makes Culbertson’s Rule better, IMHO, than alternatives is that it gets the bidder to be thinking about integrating the play into the bidding: what cards do I need from partner (that are consistent with the auction as a whole) to make the contract I am aiming for laydown?  The “perfect minimum” aspect of the Rule keeps a player from getting too ambitious: if you are counting on partner to have a perfect maximum, you will frequently be disappointed; and if are counting on partner to have a hugely imperfect minimum, you are going to miss too many good games or slams.

What brings this discussion to the blog is this hand: spadeA  heartAJ9632  diamondJ9  clubKJ83.  You open 1heart and partner raises to 2heart.  Are you worth a game try?  Culbertson’s Rule thinking might follow the lines of well, if partner holds heart Kxxx and clubQ, game should be pretty close to laydown, right?  Your methods will determine how you try for game, but since a perfect minimum of 5 HCP might produce a near-laydown game, surely some sort of game try is in order.

Another example (slightly adjusted, for author license) from the same club game as the hand above.  Let’s say that you are playing weak notrumps, which causes you to open 1club holding spadeKQ84 heartK2 diamondAJ5 clubKJ54.  LHO doubles and partner raises to 2club.  RHO passes.  Do you bid more on your balanced 17 count?  Well, applying Culbertson’s rule, you “give” partner clubATxxx and diamondQ, fitting nicely with your two diamond honors.  You expect a heart lead, and you can quickly see that 3NT is far from laydown.  Ergo, you pass.  Sure, partner might have enough for game because his auction is not inconsistent with his owning the same hand as shown above but with the spadeA instead of the diamondQ.  But that hand is not a perfect minimum and so you should not bid on.

MAS DEL MISMO AUTOR

Psychological Coups By Ely Culbertson

In bridge as in every other activity, perfect technique, tho highly desirable, is not the ultima thule. After a player has learned all there is to know about ...

Bridge & Humor

My love would you like to stay in bed, watch movies and eat popcorn?

Wroclaw 2016: Friday, September 16th

Four bronze medals were earned on Friday, the prelude to the last three sessions of the Open, Women’s, Senior and Mixed Teams, where four teams are...Photo de Jerry Li

WBF 2015: Headline News

The 42nd World Bridge Team Championships and the 10th World Transnational Open Teams Championship will be held at ....

The saga Continues: Israel Withdraws from Bermuda Bowl

The Israel Bridge Federation has just announced (at 1.30 p.m. Israel time on Saturday, September 5) that Israel will not compete in the upcoming 2015 Bermuda Bowl. Photo: Gilad Ophir

Franck Riehm elected as WBF President

The World Bridge Federation is pleased to announce the...

1st South American Online Mixed Teams Championship

All players belonging to any NBO affiliated to the WBF are welcome!

I Brazilian Online Bridge Festival 2020

Some of the best players in the world are Brazilians, and some of the most enthusiastic players too! Our Brazilian Online Festival has appeal to players of all levels. Your team will play in a friendly but competitive atmosphere, with very well-organized scoring and experienced Directors to ensure a pleasant experience for all.

WBF Robot Tournaments

Come and join the competition through our Providers, BBO, Funbridge and Ourgame, all offering you this great opportunity – we look forward to some challenging tournaments!”

The Endplay

An endplay (also throw-in), in bridge, is a tactical play where a defender is put on lead at a strategic moment, and then has to make a play that loses one or more tricks.

The Scissors Coup by John Brown

Scissors coup (or, Scissor coup, ) is a type of coup in bridge, so named because it cuts communications between defenders.

World Bridge Federation – Youth

The Championship is open to all players born on or after 1st January 1992 (Juniors & Girls) or born on or after 1st January 1997 (Youngsters) or born on or after 1st January 2002 (Kids) in good standing with their own NBOs.

Prevent a Ruff by Jon Brown

West led his singleton club, which dummy's king won. South read the lead as a singleton.

RELACIONADOS

CATEGORIAS POPULARES